Images de page
[merged small][ocr errors][ocr errors][ocr errors][ocr errors][ocr errors][ocr errors][ocr errors]

that Christ has already fulfilled all moral arities of the Gospel, many interest-
obligations in our stead. The Antinomian ing observations on the state of
surmounts this incongruity; and its ad- heathen knowledge and belief re-
vocates accordingly have availed them- specting futurity, which, independ-
selves of the advantage :-Since, say they, ently of the purpose to which he
as to exempt us from suffering ourselves
, applies them, are worthy of perusal

by parity of reasoning, the good works for the sake of the insight which
which He performed, -the personal holi- they give into the moral state of a
ness he possessed, — being imputed to us, large and enlightened portion of
as performed for us and in our stead, mankind. But the chief substance
must, in like manner, exeinpt us from any
such performance of our own." Difficul of his opinions on this important
ties, pp. 215, 216.

subject is exhibited in his View of We do not admit, however, that the Scripture Revelations concernthe practical tendency of the doc. ing a Future State. There he speaks, trine can be disposed of so shortly. first, of the revelation of immortality Even the death of Christ has not through the Gospel ; secondly, of exempted us from the necessity of the intermediate state of the soul; dying, though to believers it has and, lastly, of the condition of the disarmed death of its sting; and just blessed in heaven : on each of which so the obedience of Christ has not particulars we must offer some reexempted us from the duty of obe- marks. dience, though it has disarmed the With respect to the revelation of law of its terrors, and rendered that immortality, in the first place, Dr. duty practicable to believers from Whately understands the declarawhich they would otherwise shrink. tion of St. Paul, that Jesus Christ For the very end for which the righ- brought life and immortality to teousness of Christ is imputed to light through the Gospel, to import them, is, that they may have access that he then made the first revelato him with filial confidence and tion of that truth; for he thinks gratitude, and thence be enabled to that the Jews, unless from the ocrender him that affectionate service casional allusions of some of the which, without a sense of pardon, later Prophets, knew nothing of it, and a consciousness of acceptance, and, consequently, that the old faand therefore (we should say) with-thers did look only for transitory out the imputation of a righteous. promises. He elsewhere says (Pe. ness which they do 'not of them- culiarities, p. 5), that even what selves possess, would be impossible; little knowledge he considers some and it would indeed be a perversion of the Jews to have obtained, was of the whole scheme and design of derived, not from revelation, but the Gospel—though, it must be ad. from “ their own reason," or from mitted, a perversion far too com- “ the neighbouring nations." mon—if the means and aids afforded

This question is a matter of no hy it were construed into a licence small moment for the right appreto disregard the end.

hension of the doctrines of the Old We may next bring into view the Testament; for if the piety of observations which Dr. Whately David, for example, had reference makes on a future state. These only to the present life, it can hardly are found chiefly in an anonymous furnish us with a model : nor indeed volume, which, even if it were not is it likely, that, under such circumcurrently attributed to him, and stances, the expressions of his devodedicated to his parishioners as dis- tional feeling in the Psalms should courses preached among them “ by be so lively and animated as not to their pastor," bears too strong an in- be surpassed, if equalled, by the external evidence of his authorship to pressions of any Christian writer, be mistaken. He makes, indeed, in inspired or uninspired, on similar his Essays on some of the Peculi-' occasions. Still, if St. Paul meant

[ocr errors][ocr errors][merged small][ocr errors][merged small]
[blocks in formation]

this, when he said that Jesus Christ we think scripturally, that “ they brought life and immortality to light are not to be heard which feign through the Gospel, strange as it that the old fathers did look only appears, it must be so.

Let us

for transitory promises.” We do therefore consider what his mean not maintain, indeed, that the ing really was in this declaration. first revelation of the doctrine was

The word here translated “to through Moses: for all the revebring to light,” is often used in the lations through Moses were addiNew Testament, but generally ap- tions to revelations made before ; plied to persons. So in John i. 9, and we believe this revelation to Ην το φως το αληθινον, ο φωτιζει have been coeval with man. But, Favta av pwrov. Here our Saviour says Dr. Whately, Have we any is represented as giving light to proof of this opinion ? Our answer every man. Again, in Heb. vi. 9, is as follows : We are bound, by by rovç årat qurilεvraç are evi- the text of St. Paul already cited, dently meant persons who have once to admit that the ancient fathers received a kind and degree of light did not know of immortal life prewhich they did not enjoy before. cisely as we know of it. But the The word may commonly be ren force of his expression is not condered to “ throw light upon," or to travened, if only we allow, for ex“ enlighten,” that which was either ample, that they did not possess the dark or obscure : and so here our evidence derived from the resurblessed Saviour is said to have de- rection, as well as the teaching, of feated death, and thrown light upon Christ; but had only some less dethe incorruptible life which follows. fined expectations of what has to us It cannot be inferred from this state, been made a subject of actual dement that nothing was before known monstration. We have no doubt, of life and immortality, but only indeed, that some obscurity hung that the knowledge of them was over the subject; but that the obscure and uncertain. The ques. hopes of any true servant of God tion whether any thing at all was were ever confined exclusively to known of them before, is undeter- this life, we cannot be brought to mined by that expression; though believe. When the prophecy was it is plainly implied that whatever indirectly communicated to Adam, knowledge was possessed of them in the Divine sentence pronounced was comparatively faint and indis- upon the serpent ; " I will put entinct. Now, with respect to the mity between thee and the woman, ancient heathens, we concede that and between thy seed and her Seed: they had no knowledge whatever, it shall bruise thy head, and thou properly speaking, of a future state. shalt bruise bis heel ;" can it be The fictions of poets and the dreams supposed that his hopes were diof philosophers were, we should rected by it to a deliverance to be imagine, perverted relics of early afterwards granted to his posterity, traditions, and rather intimate that but of which he was not to be a something was once known of them, partaker? Or if, as is possible, he than that all was dark from the be. then expected to witness this proginning. The arguments suggested mised deliverance in the present by the philosophers were probably life, is it to be believed, that, when rather subsequent reasonings to

he found it to be delayed through substantiate a traditional opinion, his life, he had no hope in his death? which, when once known, appeared The contrary seems to be taught by certainly reasonable, than the ante the Apostle, when he says, Heb. cedent basis on which the opinion xi. 13, 14, 16, " These all died in was first grounded But of the Is. faith, not having received the proraelites our firm persuasion is very mises, but having seen them afar different. Our Church holds, and off; and were persuaded of them,

[merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small]


Review of Works by Dr. Whately.

and embraced them, and confessed concerning her brother : “ I know
that they were strangers and pil- that he shall rise again in the resur-
grims on the earth. These all, rection at the last day.” And that
Abel, Noah, Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, this hope was entertained by them
Sarah, died in hope : "for they that at least as far back as the time of
say such things " as they confessed David, is plain from his own solemn
of themselves, “ declare plainly asseveration : “ As for me, I will
that they seek a country.” They behold thy face in righteousness ;
seek a better country; “ that is, a and when I awake up after thy like-
heavenly.” It may be presumed, ness, I shall be satisfied with it"
indeed, that this hope became (Psal.xvii. 15): from which it appears,
weaker in process of time, through first, That he expected some great
the prevalence of iniquity; and the advantage when he should awake up
translation of Enoch might be effect. from the sleep of death ; secondly,
ed, among other reasons, to keep it That the advantage he looked for
alive. It again grew weaker after consisted in the likeness of God;
the Flood; and therefore, the rest of and thirdly, That he knew that this
the world being abandoned to their blessing, when attained, would com-
own delusions, Abraham and his pletely satisfy him. It is true, in-
posterity were called, to preserve deed, that there are other expres-
the hope of the promise made to sions in the Book of Psalms, as well
the fathers. Afterwards, the Law of as also in the prayer of Hezekiah,
Moses was added, not to extend the quoted by Dr. Whately, which may
promises of God, but to guard those seem at variance with this truth.
already made; and therefore, were The strongest, perbaps, is that in
it granted that the sanctions of the Psal. vi. 4, 5, « Return, O Lord;
Mosaical law were not in any degree deliver my soul : Oh save me, for
drawn from another life, which was thy mercies sake: for in death
the chief good at issue, but from there is no remembrance of thee;
this, it would only prove that it was in the grave who shall give thee
intended that, from the experience thanks?" Yet it is so incredible,
of the faithfulness of God to his

so contrary to the whole scheme of word in this life, a perverse genera- the Bible, so inconsistent with the tion might learn to rely on his pro- warmth and fervour of the devotion mises for another. But it is demon- of the sacred writers, as well as with strable that the hopes of true Is- their own language on other ocraelites were not limited to these 'casions, that such should have been temporary enactments: they looked their meaning, that we are comforward to something beyond the pelled to look again at the passages, grave; though they may not, in many and see if they do not properly bear instances, have ascertained with dis- a very different construction to that tinctness--such distinctness as we

put upon them. Now we find, that, enjoy under the Gospel—what it was. whatever may be alleged to have Yet what does Saint Paul say of been the notions of the writers (or, their hope, in his speech to Agrippa? more properly, the declarations of “I stand and am judged for the hope the Holy Ghost by them) of a benefit of the promise made of God unto beyond the grave, their ideas of the fathers; unto which promise our duty were justly on this side of it ; twelve tribes, instantly serving God and it was to this only they were day and night, hope to come.” (Acts referring. If they were to praise xxvi. 6,7.) Now that hope is in the God; to declare his truth, his lovingnext verse expressly stated to be, kindness, his faithfulness, his wonthat God should raise the dead. Of ders, and his righteousness; it must which hope Martha distinctly ex- be done before they descended to pressed her assurance, in her me. the land where all things are formorable confession to our Saviour gotten-that is, forgotten, not by

[ocr errors]
[ocr errors]
[ocr errors]
[ocr errors]
[ocr errors]
[merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small]

the omniscient Jehovah, but by the perversions of revealed truth, than passing generations which occupy creations of an inventive fancy. Nor successively the face of the globe. must it be omitted, that two of the They therefore asked for a conti- ancient prophets, Isaiah and Ezenuation of life, that they might do kiel, by predicting the future resomething for the promotion of his storation of Israel under the figure cause, and witness something of its of a resurrection (Isa.xxvi.19; Ezek. progress, besides making advancesin xxxvii. 12, 13,) clearly indicate that their own meetness for that life which the doctrine of a resurrection from was to follow. Accordingly, amidst the dead must in their days have Hezekialı's petitions for lengthen- been familiar to their countrymen. ed days, we find him occupied in And, in fact, our Lord himself tells observing what is the life, not of the us that the Jews of his day did body, but of the spirit ; for of that think that even in the Scriptures of alone could it be said that it is pro- the Old Testament they had eternal moted by sorrow, penitence, and life (John v.39); though Dr.Whately faith. “O Lord, by these things seems to imagine they were mismen live; and in all these things is taken in so thinking. Indeed, we the life ofthe spirit.” (Isa.xxxviii. 16.) cannot refrain from expressing our We are therefore persuaded to say surprise at the stress which he lays, nothing of various strong and ex in this whole argument, upon the pressive passages, wbich, though dis- meaning of the words pwritw and puted, we do not think fairly dis. ĉokew : although the former is freputable that the old fathers looked quently applied to the illumination forward universally (that is, all the of an obscure as well as of a dark faithful

among them looked forward) object; and the latter, with an into the complete fruition of God's finitive, is often little more than a promises after death; though they periphrasis. Thus OOKOUVTEC APXELV knew not many particulars, more (Mark x.42) does not mean less than fully revealed in the Gospel, as to apxovtec (Matt. xx. 25); nor will the

way in which they should enjoy Dr.Whately, we are confident, teach them. And yet it is probable that that Saint Paul doubted his own their notions on these matters were inspiration, when he said Aokw ĉe far more enlarged and correct than καγω πνευμα θεου εχειν. (1 Cor. we can trace them to have been, in vii. 40.) the portion of their writings which It would be very painful to us, remains to us. Indeed, Dr. Whately and may be unnecessary, to express himself acknowledges that the doc- all we feel relative to the hardihood trine of a future state was, at the of some of Dr. Whately's remarks time of our Lord's coming, the be- and conjectures on this and several lief of the greater part (the Pha- other subjects, more especially in risees and their followers) among parochial sermons, which, being the Jews; though the sect of the preached to “a mixed congregaSadducees reject it.” (View, p. 22.) tion, consisting principally of the unAnd Saint Paul himself, besides the learned,” ought to have been pecupassage already quoted, says of the liarly free from those rash and unmartyrs in still earlier times, that edifying, and we think unscriptural,

they were tortured, not accepting speculations in which they abound. deliverance, that they might obtain We mention this once for all, that in a better resurrection” (Heb. xi. 35); our passing observations on some of which favours the idea of a primitive his statements, with a view to shew revelation, inashiuch as correct no

their unsoundness, we may not seem, tions upon such a subject could not by our abstinence from the lanbe human discoveries: and even the guage of animadversion, to imply errors entertained upon


among that we do not appreciate their danthe heathen are more likely to be ger. We do feel very strongly as

thee; thee

[merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small]
[merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small]

respects the complexion of many This indeed is a position susceptible parts of these volumes ; and most of illustration, as well as of demonseriously do we mourn over such stration ; for instances bave occurred speculations, and regret their ap- of apparently suspended animation, pearance before an unthinking and of unnaturally protracted sleep, and ungodly world, especially in this some also of mental derangement, age of scepticism, neology, and he- in which the recovered patient has resy; but we have thought that we been altogether unaware of any inshall best subserve the cause of truth terval having elapsed between the by confining ourselves to a calm commencement of that state of disreply to particular statements, rather order and its termination. But, on than by general expressions of cen- the other hand, the reader may resure, which rather close than open collect the ingenious tale in the the ear to truth.

Spectator, in which a person is made On the intermediate state of the to dream that he passes through a soul after death, which Dr. Whately series of adventures, occupying a discusses at some length, he cor course of many years, in the inrectly states, that

terval of dipping his head into water “One thing is perfectly clear and cer

and lifting it up again. These optain, that it is not a state of trial and proba. posite cases may concur to shew tion,-a state in which any thing can take how little the actual lapse of time place to affect a man's final condition ; (as is connected with the sense of it. the Romanists pretend,) since we are

We plainly taught in Scripture that this pre


also further concede to sent life is the whole of our state of trial, the ingenious author, that an interand that we shall be judged at the last mediate state of consciousness is not day according to our conduct here on earth.” View, p. 51.

in so many words among the direct

positive revelations of Scripture. We He adds,

are here, however, desirous to observe, “Since then the intermediate state is that many things are distinctly intinot one of trial, it must be either one of enjoyment and suffering according to each mated there, which are not in so man's character, (that is, a state of reward many words directly and positively and punishment,) or else a state of utter revealed. We may explain our insensibility, and unconsiousness; either meaning by an illustration. We may of which opinions may, I think, be safely entertained (though only one of them can

suppose a father willing to convey be true), without failing in any part of the

to his son some notion of the future faith which it is essential for a Christian fortune which awaits him. The to hold." p. 51.

shortest way to do this would be, He then exhibits some of the ar to tell him at once the amount of guments for that state being a income which it would annually state of con

ousness, and some of place at his disposal, But this those which favour. its being a precise statement, we will suppose, state of insensibility; and after a he, for some reason judged inexpereview of both, he draws the con- dient. He might think, for example, clusion, that either of them has that an inexperienced young persome evidence of probability on its son would have no adequate idea behalf, but has yet to conflict with of the difference, in the command of equally probable evidence on the comforts, which a smaller or larger otber.

income would afford him ; while the Now we readily concede te Dr. sanguine anticipations of youth Whately, that, if this intermediate would tempt him to expect from a state were one of entire insensibility, smaller sum greater advantages than the moment of resurrection would be, could actually be procured by a to the consciousness of each indi- much larger.' He might therefore vidual, though at the end of ten prefer giving him by little and little thousand years, the same thing as if some occasional intimations of what it took place the instant after death. might be effected with his future

[ocr errors][ocr errors][ocr errors][ocr errors][ocr errors][ocr errors][merged small][ocr errors][ocr errors][ocr errors][ocr errors]
« PrécédentContinuer »